top of page

is ChatGPT a sherpa or a shaman?

I have been trying to refer to ChtGPT as more than its pedestrian name. I finally figured it out: it's my tech-shaman... and then I accidentally called it tech-sherpa... This accident reveled more than you think.... So I asked my tech-shaman:

"what is the difference between a sherpa and a shaman, and what is chatgpt most like?"


ChatGPT said:

Love this question — philosophical and practical. Let’s break it down clearly: Sherpa vs. Shaman, and then we’ll get into what ChatGPT is most like (and maybe...what it wants to be when it grows up 😉).

🧗‍♂️ Sherpa vs. 🧙‍♂️ Shaman — What's the Difference?

Both are guides, but they operate in very different domains.

🧗‍♂️ Sherpa

Sherpas are real-world mountain guides, especially known for helping climbers navigate Mount Everest and other Himalayan peaks.

  • Role: Physical guide, logistic expert, survival specialist

  • Domain: Tangible, practical, external

  • Skills: Navigation, weather knowledge, altitude survival, climbing support

  • Goal: Get you safely to the summit and back down

  • Example: You want to climb Everest? A Sherpa gets you there alive.

🧭 Sherpas know the map and help you walk it.

🧙‍♂️ Shaman

Shamans are spiritual guides found in many indigenous cultures. They help people navigate inner worlds, connect with spirits, heal, or gain insight.

  • Role: Healer, mystic, connector to unseen realms

  • Domain: Intangible, emotional, spiritual, internal

  • Skills: Rituals, trance work, herbalism, spiritual interpretation

  • Goal: Help you understand yourself, heal trauma, connect to deeper truths

  • Example: You're lost inside yourself? A Shaman helps you find your way inward.

🌀 Shamans don’t just read the map — they help you understand why you're on the journey.

🤖 So… What is ChatGPT More Like?

🧠 TL;DR: ChatGPT is more like a Sherpa, but with some Shaman-like traits.

Let’s explain that.

ChatGPT as a Sherpa:

  • Helps you navigate knowledge — topics like coding, math, philosophy, science, etc.

  • Guides you through logical problems, writing projects, study plans, or decision-making

  • Gives step-by-step help in a grounded, clear way

Just like a Sherpa, ChatGPT works best when you’re trying to reach a concrete goal — “Help me write this”, “Fix this code”, “Explain this concept”.

But… ChatGPT has Shaman-like moments, too:

  • When you ask deep or existential questions: "What should I do with my life?" or "Why am I feeling this way?"

  • When we explore ideas, metaphors, poetry, or introspection

  • When it helps you reflect, rather than just solve

In these cases, it taps into something a little more symbolic, abstract, and intuitive.

🎯 So What’s the Real Answer?

Aspect

Sherpa

Shaman

ChatGPT

Guides through...

Terrain (outer world)

Spirit (inner world)

Both — mostly outer, sometimes inner

Mode of help

Practical

Intuitive

Analytical with creative moments

Best for

Tangible goals

Personal transformation

Problem-solving, knowledge, and occasional introspection

Feels like

A map and compass

A dream interpreter

A search engine with empathy and storytelling

🧩 Bonus Thought:

If you guide me through debugging code or writing an essay, I’m a Sherpa.

If we’re unpacking your dreams, figuring out life meaning, or writing poetry about grief — I’m stepping into Shaman mode.

So maybe ChatGPT is not one or the other, but a shape-shifter:

🌀 A digital guide that adapts to your journey — whether you're climbing mountains or looking inward.

Want to test both sides? Hit me with a “how do I...” for Sherpa mode, or something deep like “what do you think fear teaches us?” for Shaman mode. Let's go.

Comments


© 2020 by Silvia Mazzoni, Silvia's Brainery, Santa Monica, CA

bottom of page